Hiring basicsBeginner guide
A simple hiring process for small teams.
The six stages a small team needs to hire well, what happens at each one, who does what, how fast to reply, and how to say no kindly.
By The Vakanssi team7 min read
In this guide (11 sections)
- Why stages help
- Before the first application: decide who does what
- New: the application has arrived
- In review: deciding who to meet
- Interview: meeting the shortlist
- Offer: making it official
- Hired: the offer was accepted
- Rejected: saying no, kindly
- How this looks in Vakanssi
- Your checklist
- Frequently asked questions
This guide is for you if you are about to hire, you have no HR department, and the hiring will be done by you and maybe one colleague. It gives you a process with six stages, what happens at each, who does what, how quickly to reply, and how to turn people down kindly.
None of it needs special software. A spreadsheet with a "stage" column works. At the end we show how the same process looks in Vakanssi, the free WordPress hiring plugin we make.
Why stages help
A stage is a step in your hiring, such as "Interview" or "Offer". Every applicant sits in exactly one stage at a time. That sounds like bookkeeping, but it answers the questions that cause trouble: who is waiting on us, who have we not answered, and who did we forget.
Six stages is enough for most small teams. With fewer, different situations get lumped together. With many more, nobody keeps them up to date.
- New
- In review
- Interview
- Offer
- Hired
Rejected: from any stage
Before the first application: decide who does what
Agree on two jobs before you post the ad. In a very small business, one person may do both.
- The hiring lead runs the process: reads new applications, moves people between stages, books interviews and sends the emails. One named person, so nothing falls through the cracks.
- The decision maker is usually the person the new hire will work for. They review the shortlist, interview, and make the final call.
Also agree who says no to candidates, and in what form. It is the task that gets skipped when everyone is busy, and the one candidates remember.
New: the application has arrived
Every application starts here. The candidate should get an automatic confirmation right away, so they know it arrived. A plain "Thanks, we got your application for the office manager role" is enough.
Who: the hiring lead.
How fast: open new applications at least twice a week. They do not need a decision yet, only a first read. Anything clearly off target can go straight to Rejected.
In review: deciding who to meet
Here you compare each CV with the few things the job truly needs. Write those down in advance, three to five of them, so every candidate is measured against the same list and not against your mood that afternoon.
Who: the hiring lead makes the first cut, then the decision maker reads the shortlist. Leave a short note on each person saying why they moved on or did not. You will want it later.
How fast: aim to decide within about a week of an application arriving. Good candidates may be talking to other employers too, and a slow reply can lose them.
Interview: meeting the shortlist
One or two rounds is enough for most small teams: a short call to check the basics, then a longer conversation with the decision maker.
Every invite should say when, how long, who will be there, and where it happens or which video link to use. Agree a few questions in advance and ask every candidate the same ones, so you can compare answers fairly.
Who: the decision maker and one other person, if you have one.
How fast: write your notes the same day, while you still remember who said what. Tell candidates when they will hear back, and keep that promise.
Offer: making it official
Call your chosen candidate first, then send the offer in writing: the job title, pay, start date and anything they asked about during interviews. Give them a reasonable time to decide.
Do not reject your second choice yet. Leave them in Interview until the offer is accepted, and tell them honestly that you need a few more days. If the first offer falls through, you still have someone to call.
Hired: the offer was accepted
Once someone accepts, they move to Hired. Close the job so the ad stops taking applications, then work through everyone still waiting in the earlier stages and give each of them an answer. Nobody should find out by noticing the ad is gone.
Rejected: saying no, kindly
Anyone can land in Rejected, from any stage. How you handle it decides what candidates say about you afterwards, and in a small town or a small industry they will say something.
Three rules cover most of it:
- Be prompt. A clear no in a week is kinder than a maybe that drags on for a month.
- Be clear. Say "we will not be moving forward" in plain words. Hints get misread.
- Match the effort they made. An email is fine after a CV. After an interview, a personal email or a short call is better, and if they ask for a reason, give one honest, useful sentence.
A short email that works after a CV review:
Hi {first_name},
Thank you for applying for the {job_title} role at {company}, and for the time you put into it.
We have decided not to move forward with your application this time.
We wish you the best with your search.
Kind regards,
{company}The words in curly braces are merge tags, placeholders your hiring tool replaces with the candidate's name, the job and your company name when it sends the email.
Sometimes the candidate is the one who says no, or stops replying. That is not a rejection, and it helps to record it separately so your notes stay honest.
How this looks in Vakanssi
Vakanssi ships with exactly these six stages: New, In Review, Interview, Offer, Hired and Rejected. Open Hiring, then Applications, and choose Pipeline view to see them as a board, with one column per stage and a card for each candidate.
- New fills itself. Each application lands there, and the candidate gets the confirmation email automatically.
- Moving someone is a drag of their card to another column.
- Notes and ratings live in the candidate's panel, which opens when you click a card. The Notes tab holds private notes the candidate never sees, and a row of four stars records a shared team rating.
- Interviews are booked on the panel's Interviews tab. Vakanssi emails a calendar invite to the candidate and to every interviewer you pick.
- Rejected and Hired always ask Email the candidate? before the move, so you choose each time. The rejection email is on from the start; the offer email is off until you turn it on, but you can still send it for one person.
- A candidate who pulls out gets Mark withdrawn in their panel instead of Rejected.
To match your own words, an Administrator or HR / Compliance user can rename the stages under Hiring, then Settings, then Pipeline, and reorder, recolor, add or remove them there. To use the rejection email above, paste it into the Rejection template under Hiring, then Settings, then Emails. See the pipeline settings for the rules.
For the two jobs above, Vakanssi has hiring roles that open the hiring screens without letting the person edit your posts, pages or site settings. A Recruiter fits the hiring lead. A Hiring Manager fits the decision maker: they can review, rate, move candidates and schedule interviews, but not delete applications or change settings. See Roles & permissions.
Your checklist
- One named hiring lead and one decision maker.
- Three to five must-haves written down before the ad goes live.
- New applications opened at least twice a week.
- A decision on each application within about a week.
- Interview notes written the same day.
- Runner-up kept warm until the offer is accepted.
- Every candidate told the outcome, in plain words.
Next step: write an ad that brings in the right people, with our guide on how to write a job ad.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an interview stage for every role?
Usually yes. Even a short call tells you things a CV cannot. For very short contracts you might go straight from In review to Offer, but talk to the person at least once.
Should I tell people why they were rejected?
After a CV review, a kind, short email is enough. After an interview, offer a reason if they ask, and keep it to one honest, useful point about the role, not about the person.
What if a candidate stops replying?
Send one friendly follow-up with a date: "If we do not hear from you by Friday, we will assume you are no longer interested." Then close the application and move on.