Careers pagesBeginner guide

We checked 99 small business careers pages: what went wrong.

We checked 99 small business careers pages on WordPress. The most common careers page mistakes, what each one costs you, and how to fix it.

By The Vakanssi team9 min read

A grid of 99 small page tiles, a few marked in teal, with a magnifying glass over one of them.
In this guide (11 sections)

This is for you if your business has a WordPress website and you post jobs on it, or plan to. You do not need to be technical.

On 7 November 2026 we looked at the careers pages of 99 small organisations that run WordPress: plumbers, roofers, landscapers, clinics, agencies, law and accounting firms, a few nonprofits. We checked each page for the things a job seeker, or Google, needs to find.

Below are the mistakes we saw most often, what each one costs you, and how to fix it on any WordPress site. We make a hiring plugin, so we have an interest here. That is why the method and its limits are at the end, and why we name none of the sites.

What we found

Not every check applies to every page, so each number says what it is out of.

  • A quarter named no open job. 24 of 99 pages (24%) did not name a single current opening.
  • Most put every job on one page. Of the 58 sites that described their jobs on their own site, 45 (78%) put them all on the careers page. Only 12 (21%) gave each job its own page.
  • Google's job data was almost always missing. Of those 58, 4 (7%) had it.
  • Pay was usually left out. Of the 56 sites where we could read the job details, 21 (38%) showed a figure.
  • Some took applications by email only. 13 of 99 (13%).
  • Two things were fine. All 99 had the basic setting that fits a page to a phone screen, and 92 of 99 (93%) were linked from the header menu.
  • Named no current opening24 of 99 (24%)
  • Gave each job its own page12 of 58 (21%)
  • Had Google's job data4 of 58 (7%)
  • Showed a pay figure21 of 56 (38%)
  • Took applications by email only13 of 99 (13%)
  • Linked from the header menu92 of 99 (93%)
Each bar is out of the pages that check applied to: all 99, the 58 that described their jobs on their own site, or the 56 where we could read the job details.

Mistake 1: no specific job on the page

Of the 24 pages without a current opening, 19 said something like "we are always looking for good people" without naming a job. The other 5 said plainly that there were no openings, which is honest and fine.

Another 11 of the 99 named no jobs on their own page at all. They only linked to a list on an outside hiring service.

What it costs you. A vague invitation gets vague applications, or none. People looking for work often search for a job title and a town, such as "roofer Denver". A page that never names the job gives search engines nothing to match.

How to fix it. Name each opening: the job title, where the work is, the hours, and a few lines on what the person will do. If you are not hiring, say so in one sentence and tell people how to hear about the next opening.

Mistake 2: every job on one long page

Of the 58 sites that described their jobs themselves, 45 put them all on the careers page, one under the other. One more kept the details in PDF files.

What it costs you. You cannot send someone a link to one job, and nobody can share it. It also blocks Google's job search. Google's job posting rules say its job data "must only be used on pages that contain a single job posting". A page listing five jobs cannot carry it properly.

How to fix it. Give each job its own page, and keep the careers page as the list that links to them. You do not need a plugin for this. Go to Pages, then Add Page (older versions say Add New Page), and write the job.

In the settings panel on the right, find Parent and choose your careers page. Then link to the new page from your careers page.

Mistake 3: nothing for Google's job search to read

Google for Jobs is the box of job listings Google shows when someone searches for work. To fill it, Google reads hidden labels on a job page, called structured data. The kind for jobs is named JobPosting. Visitors never see it.

Only 7 of the 99 sites had any. Of the 58 that described their jobs on their own site, 4 did. And only 2 of the 7 passed our basic look:

  • 2 sat on pages that named no specific job, which Google's rules do not allow.
  • 1 was on a page listing two jobs instead of one.
  • 1 belonged to a job whose own closing date had passed in February.
  • 1 had broken code that a computer cannot read.

What it costs you. Your job does not appear in that search box. Google also says it does not allow expired job postings, and that leaving them up can lead to action against your site.

How to fix it. First give each job its own page (mistake 2). Then use a job plugin that adds JobPosting data for you, or an SEO plugin with a job posting option. Paste the job's address into Google's free Rich Results Test to check it. When the job is filled, take the page down.

Mistake 4: no pay

Of the 56 sites where we could read the job details, 35 (62%) gave no pay figure. 14 of them wrote "competitive pay" or similar instead, which tells a candidate nothing.

What it costs you. Without a number, candidates have to guess. Some will not apply. Others find out at the first interview that the pay does not work for them, after you have both spent the time. Also check whether the rules where you hire say anything about pay in job ads. This is not legal advice.

How to fix it. Show a range and what it is per: "$24 to $30 per hour" or "£32,000 to £36,000 a year".

Mistake 5: "email your CV" and nothing else

13 of the 99 sites took applications by email with no other way in. 5 more showed no way to apply at all in the page we downloaded, though some of those may load a form with code we did not run.

What it costs you. Applications land in someone's inbox, mixed with invoices. They get missed, nobody knows who replied to whom, and CVs sit in mailboxes for years. That makes it harder to answer someone who asks what you hold about them.

How to fix it. Put an application form with a CV upload on the job page, so every application arrives the same way. Many WordPress form plugins have a file upload field for this. Check where yours stores the files: a CV in a public folder can be opened by anyone who has the link.

One more habit: look at the page

This was not one of our checks, so there is no percentage. We saw a page saying "no current opportunities" right above an open role, and another showing a closing date already past. Read your own careers page once a month.

How Vakanssi handles these

We make Vakanssi, a free hiring plugin for WordPress. Everything below is in the free plugin.

  • Named jobs, or an honest empty state. Each published job is listed by title on your careers page. With none published, the list says "There are no open positions right now." by default.
  • One page per job. Every job gets its own page with its details and an application form. See Your careers page.
  • Google's job data. Each job page gets JobPosting data built from the fields visitors see, and a readiness banner in the job editor names anything missing.
  • Closed jobs leave. When a closing date passes, the job drops off the careers page and Vakanssi withdraws it from Google. See Google for Jobs.
  • Pay. Hidden by default. You can show an exact amount or a range, per hour, day, week, month or year.
  • Applications. Candidates apply through a form with a CV upload, and every application lands under Hiring in wp-admin.

How we did this

Finding the sites. On 7 November 2026 we ran 72 web searches such as "roofing company careers Denver join our team". We varied the trade and the city across the US, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand, India, Singapore, South Africa and the Netherlands. From the results we took organisations' own careers pages, not job boards or hiring services.

Who we left out. That gave 222 sites. We removed 81 that showed no sign of WordPress and 30 whose careers page did not load for us. That includes 7 that were our fault: our script did not follow one kind of redirect, and we did not go back, to stay within our request limit.

After reading the rest, we removed 12 more: 3 that described themselves as large (over 250 staff or more than 10 locations), 3 that were not careers pages, 2 job boards, 2 franchises, 1 recruitment agency and 1 duplicate. That left 99. None used Vakanssi.

Being polite. We made at most 3 requests per site, 1.5 seconds apart: the robots.txt file (where a site says what automated visitors may fetch), the careers page and one job page. We fetched nothing robots.txt ruled out, used a normal browser identity, and never logged in or filled in a form.

The checks. A script recorded the header menu link, the phone setting and the JobPosting data. An AI model then read every page, with the same written rules for each, to judge whether it named a specific job, where the details were, how to apply and whether pay was shown. No person reviewed every call, so treat these four counts as careful estimates. Pay meant a figure for that job, not "competitive pay" or a bonus.

We dropped two checks we could not measure fairly: whether each job states its location (a town name in plain text is hard to detect reliably) and page speed (our timings came from one place on one day).

Limits of this study

  • It is a convenience sample. We found these sites through searches we chose, so they do not represent all small businesses. Most of the 99 are in the US or Canada, and trades and home services dominate.
  • An AI model made the judgement calls. Borderline pages, such as an "always hiring electricians" banner, could have gone either way, and no person re-checked each one.
  • We did not run the pages' code. Forms and job lists that load later are invisible to our method, so some sites may do better than we measured.
  • One day, and only the site itself. Careers pages change often, and we did not look at jobs hosted on outside services.

We keep the per-site data private and publish only totals.

Checklist for your careers page

  1. Each open job is named, with its title, where the work is and the hours.
  2. Each job has its own page, linked from the careers page.
  3. Each job page carries JobPosting data that passes Google's Rich Results Test.
  4. Each job shows a pay figure or range.
  5. People apply through a form with a CV upload, not only by email.
  6. Filled jobs come down, and the page says plainly when you are not hiring.

New to all this? Our guide on how to add a careers page to WordPress walks you through a page that ticks every item on this list.

Your next step

Try it on your own site.

Vakanssi is free on WordPress.org: careers page, apply form, pipeline and candidate data tools, with no time limit and no per-seat fees.

Keep reading

More guides

All guides